Skip to Content
We earn commissions from brands listed on this site, which influences how listings are presented.
4,064 Reviews

Smalls Cat Food Review

Allforyourfurbaby.com Staff
www.allforyourfurbaby.com staff is comprised of freelance writers who write for the site

October 21, 2026

•

3 min

Pets serviced
Cats only
Delivery fee
Free shipping across the continental US
Ingredient quality
Fresh, human-grade, 80%+ animal protein, gently cooked, no fillers or artificial preservatives

In a Nutshell

Smalls makes fresh, gently cooked cat food with at least 80% real animal protein and no fillers, preservatives, or artificial flavors. Every recipe is formulated with veterinary nutritionists in USDA-certified, human-grade kitchens. Plans are personalized through a short online quiz, shipping is always free, and a money-back guarantee covers your first order if your cat won't eat it.

Smalls Pros & Cons

Pros

One of only three cat food brands certified by the Clean Label Project
Human-grade ingredients from USDA-certified kitchens
Vet-formulated, complete and balanced nutrition
Free shipping on every order
Money-back guarantee if your cat won't eat it

Cons

Sampler orders can auto-enroll you in a subscription
No returns or cancellations once an order has shipped
Some customers report carrier delivery delays

Smalls

9.4
Editorial Score

Price and value for money

Vet-formulated fresh meals with human-grade, AAFCO-complete recipes for all life stages and 5 protein options
10.0

Delivery and logistics

Treats, bone broth toppers, and functional supplements
10.0

Product variety

Starting plans from approximately $3–$3.50/day, with bulk discounts reducing the daily cost
9.0

Payment options

Email, text-based Cat Concierge, and a Help Center with support available 7 days a week
9.0

Customer service

Personalized meal plans based on an online questionnaire covering age, weight, lifestyle, and health needs
9.0

How It Works

Getting started with Smalls begins with a short online quiz about your cat: age, weight, breed, activity level, and any health concerns. Based on your answers, Smalls builds a personalized meal plan and recommends a mix of recipes your cat is likely to enjoy. Most new customers start with a Sampler Pack, a smaller trial box that lets your cat try the food before you commit to a full plan.

Meals arrive frozen and gently cooked, so prep is simple: thaw in the fridge, portion according to the feeding guide included with your plan, and serve. From there, you can manage everything, delivery frequency, portion sizes, recipe swaps, or pausing and canceling, through your online account. Deliveries typically ship within about a week of ordering and arrive packed with dry ice to stay cold in transit.

Food Variety

Smalls' fresh recipes are built around whole proteins, including chicken, beef, pork, turkey, cod, and salmon, along with organ meats like liver for added nutrients. Every recipe is at least 80% animal protein, with the rest made up of vitamins, minerals, and a small amount of greens and healthy fats. Nothing is extruded or over-processed the way traditional kibble is, so meals keep more of their natural moisture and nutrition intact.

Beyond the core fresh recipes, Smalls also offers freeze-dried options for cat parents who want something with more crunch but without synthetic additives. Its freeze-dried Puffs are made with roughly 95% chicken, giving picky or texture-sensitive cats a lighter, shelf-stable alternative to standard dry food.

Safety & Testing

The Clean Label Project, an independent U.S. nonprofit, tests pet food for contaminants that never appear on ingredient labels. For its 2026 study, an ISO 17025-accredited lab screened 100 products from 62 brands for more than 122 contaminants. Only three cat food brands earned certification, and Smalls is one of them. The recipe tested was Smooth Bird & Fish Dish (Chicken & Salmon), from a single batch.
Source: Clean Label Project, CLP Insights: Cat Food Category Report (2026).

Additional Products Available

Smalls Mart rounds out the lineup with extras beyond the core meal plans. Cat-focused items include hydrating broth packs, lickable treats formulated to support digestion or skin and coat health, freeze-dried Puffy Bird in a couple of sizes, and feeding accessories like ceramic serve bowls and dishes. There's also a small line of merchandise for cat parents themselves, from apparel to totes and stickers, if you want to show off the obsession.

Pricing

Smalls doesn't publish a single flat price for its fresh food plans. Because portions are calculated per cat based on weight, age, and activity level, your exact cost is shown at checkout after you complete the quiz. Most new customers start with the lower-cost Sampler Pack before moving to a full subscription. Smalls Mart items (treats, broths, and accessories) are priced individually and can be purchased on their own.

Option

Cost

Details

Sampler Pack

Low, one-time cost

A trial box of recipes picked for your cat, shown at checkout after the quiz.

Fresh Food Subscription

Personalized weekly rate

Priced per cat based on weight, age, and activity level. Ships on your chosen schedule.

Smalls Mart add-ons

Roughly $12 to $62

Broths, treats, freeze-dried food, and feeding accessories, sold separately.

Source: smalls.com. Prices and promotions are subject to change, so always confirm current costs on the Smalls site before ordering.

Help & Support

Smalls' Cat Concierge team is available seven days a week by text or email, and the company aims to respond to inquiries within a day. Support covers everything from help transitioning your cat to fresh food to resolving issues with a delivery, and reviewers generally describe the team as responsive and easy to reach. If something goes wrong with an order, such as a damaged box or a delivery that arrives warm, reaching out promptly with your order details tends to get the fastest resolution.

What Pet Parents Have to Say About Smalls

“The fresh cooked quality ingredients give my cats optimum nutrition and sufficient hydration... Delivery, website and customer service are all easy to navigate.” — Eve

“My ultra-picky eater... hasn't touched a bite of any wet food I've offered her since November. I have tried everything available locally and finally decided to try the Smalls sampler. She DEVOURED the first plate I offered.” — Jaclyn

“The website is user friendly. My furbaby Gizmo loves the fresh food! She has even lost some weight since I started feeding Smalls to her.”— Megan

Conclusion

Smalls stands out for cat parents who want to move away from kibble without guessing at ingredient quality. The recipes are protein-heavy, human-grade, and vet-formulated, the quiz makes it easy to land on a plan suited to your specific cat, and the money-back guarantee takes some of the risk out of trying something new. The tradeoffs are mostly about subscription management: keep an eye on your renewal terms, and reach out to the Cat Concierge team early if your schedule or delivery needs change. For cat parents ready to invest in fresher food, Smalls is well worth a look.

*AI was used in the creation of this content, along with human validation and proofreading.

Allforyourfurbaby.com Staff

www.allforyourfurbaby.com staff is comprised of freelance writers who write for the site

Editorial Reviews
The Farmer's Dog
The Farmer's Dog
Read Review
Must Reads
Why Feed Your Dog Natural Fresh Food
Apr 07, 2026
What Makes Pet Food Healthy Anyway?
Apr 07, 2026
What’s the Best Dog Food for Fido & Friends?
Apr 07, 2026
Chowin’ Down the Right Way: A Closer Look at Dog Food Options
Apr 07, 2026
Why Furry Friends Prefer Fresh: Fresh Dog Food Benefits
Apr 07, 2026
Read All
Trustpilot reviews
See what some customers are saying about Smalls
Great • reviews 4,064
on
Excellent
70%
Great
10%
Average
5%
Poor
4%
Bad
12%
Tura Chee
6 days ago
Where do I even begin with the…
Where do I even begin with the exceptional customer service? This company has truly been a blessing to me and my cat! His nutrition and overall health have improved immensely since switching to their products. The food is incredibly high-quality, clean, and nutritious, and even his litter box is practically odor-free! My cat is extremely sensitive to certain foods, and many brands have caused him to throw up or have adverse reactions. This is the ONLY brand he tolerates without any issues. His body, digestive health, and overall well-being have benefited tremendously. On top of having outstanding products, their customer service is second to none. I’ve dealt with so many other companies that fail to respond to questions or address concerns, but this company goes above and beyond to make sure every question and concern is addressed promptly and thoroughly. If I could give this company 100 stars, I absolutely would! Exceptional products, exceptional customer care, and a very happy, healthy cat. What more could a pet parent ask for?
SB
Shirley Ballantyne
1 week ago
My cats love Smalls!
My cats love Smalls!
Je
Jessie
1 week ago
Chronic digestion issues are so much better
We adopted a rescue kitty with chronic diarrhea a few years ago and we've tried many foods and treatments before this. She won't eat hydrolyzed protein foods and likes a change in her food from time-to-time. Some of the recommended foods made her condition worse. Science Diet sensitive kibble in chicken and rice worked fairly well, but the vet said a wet food would be easier on her digestion. I decided to try Smalls even though I expected it to be like so many others we had tried - either she wouldn't eat it or it didn't help. Very happily, I was wrong. She loves the food and her poops are much better than they have ever been. The ground food seems to work best for her as I change things up from time to time, but she loves to eat all that we have tried so far. (I think the pulled may be a little difficult on her digestion, though she loves it.) I am so happy that Smalls is available.
Lindsey Parker
1 week ago
My cat LOVES Smalls
My cat LOVES Smalls. He is so excited when it’s time to eat. His poops are also not stinky anymore & are way less frequent. And his coat is so soft and shiny! Highly recommend!
1
2
3
...
25